Why Business Sales Fall Apart Before Closing: 6 Common Risks
- Mark Hartmann, MBA
- 9 hours ago
- 10 min read
Getting an offer in writing for your company feels great, but it doesn’t mean the money is in your account yet. There are six hurdles between signing and closing, and the good news is you can tackle most of them before a buyer ever shows up.
There’s a moment in almost every deal when the seller starts spending the money in their head, and I completely understand it. After twenty or thirty years of building the business, there’s finally a real offer for what you built.
But between that offer and the wire transfer, there’s a 60- to 120-day window where things can go sideways. Deals don’t always fall apart during the big negotiations. They sometimes unravel quietly over issues that have been sitting in plain sight for months.
There are six main risks that can trip up a closing in lower-middle-market deals. The good news is, if you tackle them early, you can often reduce, price, or even eliminate most of them. Let’s walk through each one, why it pops up, and what you can do to stay ahead of it.
1. The Buyer’s Money Is a Condition, Not a Fact.
An offer tells you what a buyer wants to pay. It doesn’t always mean they actually have the money lined up.
Many lower-middle-market transactions depend on outside financing or third-party equity. A buyer-commissioned or lender-required Quality of Earnings (QoE) review, appraisal, or other financial diligence can affect the available capital and force a change in structure.
A credit committee can decline. An investment committee can reprioritize. An appraisal or a lender’s own QoE can come back short and force a restructuring of the capital stack, which lands on you as a lower price or a larger seller note.
The timing risk matters just as much as the failure risk. Financing delays stretch the exclusivity period, and every extra week you’re tied up with one buyer is a week you’re off the market—and they know it.
So qualify capacity before you grant exclusivity, not after.
Who's providing the equity, and is that capital committed or still being raised?
Is the debt a term sheet or a real credit approval, and who's the lender?
How many acquisitions has this buyer closed in the last two years, and who were the advisors on them?
A credible buyer should provide clear, verifiable answers appropriate to the stage of the process. Evasion, inconsistency, or an unwillingness to demonstrate a credible path to closing often shows the difference between real interest and someone who’s just kicking tires.
2. Diligence Finds Something in Almost Every Deal. What Matters Is Whether You Already Knew.
Buyers are going to dig. That’s their job. The difference between a small hiccup and a big price cut often comes down to whether you already knew about the issue before they did.
I had a deal where a public company was buying a private one, and the private company was very well run. Ninety out of a hundred. Strong operations, solid financials, everything looked good on the surface. Then, diligence revealed gaps in internal HR compliance. No lawsuits, nothing criminal, just sloppy documentation and inconsistent policies that a public company can't ignore.
The seller didn't think it was a big deal. His reaction was that they'd been running this way for years. The buyer said they couldn't move forward until it was cleaned up. That stalled the deal, and I ended up refereeing until the seller made the changes and the buyer came back to the table.
Even the best-run companies can hit a snag during diligence. That’s the part many owners underestimate.
The best defense is to get ahead of it. Do a sell-side quality of earnings review, pull together a documented add-back file, and have your legal and HR ducks in a row before you go to market. That way, you’re the one finding the issues while you still have leverage and time to fix them.
3. Your Paperwork Has to Support What Your Financials Claim.
This one isn’t flashy, but it’s one of the most common reasons closings get delayed.
Purchase agreements are built on disclosure schedules, and disclosure schedules are built on documents. Your attorney can’t schedule a contract that nobody can find.
The recurring problems are ordinary: a corporate record book that stopped being updated in 2011, a stock ledger that doesn’t match what the owners believe they own, customer agreements that were renewed by email instead of by amendment, equipment on the balance sheet with no title, software and designs built by contractors who never signed an assignment, employee agreements that were never countersigned.
Each of these issues might seem minor on its own. But together, they can leave you scrambling to pull paperwork at the last minute or making promises your attorney will warn you not to make. Either way, it costs you time and money.
What to do now: Pull your corporate record book, your cap table, and signed copies of your ten largest customer and vendor contracts. If you can’t produce all of it within a day, you’ve just found your first pre-market project. |
4. Some of the Approvals You Need Aren’t Yours to Give.
Many owners think closing is just between them and the buyer. In reality, there are often third parties who get a say in whether the deal goes through.
Leases. Many leases and material contracts require consent to an assignment, and some also require consent to a change of control. Review the actual language and the contemplated transaction structure before assuming whether consent is required.
Customer and vendor contracts. Change-of-control and assignability provisions mean a customer can be asked to approve the transaction and can decline.
Environmental review. Transactions involving industrial operations or real estate may trigger state-specific requirements for notice, investigation, remediation, or approval requirements. Certain professional and trade licenses may also require a qualified individual or a new application after a change in ownership. Identify those requirements before the deal timetable is set.
Trade licensing. The license often attaches to a person rather than to the company, so the buyer must have, hire, or qualify a license holder before closing. Certain professional and trade licenses may also require a qualified individual or a new application after a change in ownership. Identify those requirements before the deal timetable is set.
Healthcare credentialing and surety. Payer enrollment timelines and the re-establishment of bonding capacity under new ownership both run on schedules that nobody in the deal controls.
None of these are unusual. The real risk is that these approvals run on someone else’s timeline, while your exclusivity clock keeps ticking with the buyer.
Some of this work really does have to wait until you have a buyer, but you can start the inventory now. Before you go to market, know which consents you’ll need, how long they usually take, and which ones you can tackle at the same time. An advisor with experience in your industry can help you map this out.
5. Buyer Behavior Is a Risk Category, Not a Personality Problem.
Once you’re under exclusivity, some buyers change their tune. Suddenly, prices get revisited, small requests start piling up, and timelines stretch out.
Sometimes a buyer has a real reason to renegotiate, and when that happens, you deal with it. But other times, they bring up issues you disclosed months ago and act like they’re brand new. Those little requests add up—I call it death by a thousand cuts. Each one seems minor, but together, they can cost you real money.
Delays work the same way. A buyer who lets the process drag out knows that fatigue can do their negotiating for them.
Your protections aren’t flashy, but they work. Keep track of what you disclosed and when, so if something comes up late, you have proof. Keep your options open for as long as the LOI allows, because buyers act differently when they know you have choices. And let your advisor handle the tough conversations, so you’re not the one arguing with your future business partner late at night.
6. The One Risk You Fully Control Is the Business Itself
I tell every seller the same thing: my job is to run the deal, and your job is to keep running the business.
The buyer is paying for the path your business is on. If that path changes while they’re watching, they have a real reason to ask for a price cut. And it’s tough to argue with them. Miss your numbers during diligence, and you’ve just handed them the best excuse to renegotiate. If you have a great quarter during diligence, it rarely bumps up the price, but it might help you get better terms on things like escrow or seller financing.
Performance risk isn’t just about the numbers. If a key employee leaves, a big customer gets nervous, or your own health slows things down, the business the buyer thought they were getting starts to look different. Keep pushing on sales. Collect your receivables faster than ever. Focus your time on what drives results, and let someone else handle the paperwork.
What to do now: Decide who owns the diligence response before you sign an LOI, and make sure it isn’t the same person responsible for revenue. When the same person is responsible for revenue and diligence, operating performance can suffer at exactly the wrong time. |
Closing Risk Gets More Expensive the Later You Find It
If you look at those six risks, you’ll see that most—financing, diligence, paperwork, third-party approvals, and business performance—can be spotted and managed before you even have a buyer. Buyer behavior is the risk over which the seller generally has the least control.
That’s why preparation matters so much. The further you get into a deal, the more expensive these risks become, because your leverage shifts. An environmental approval that’s just a box to check in March can turn into a crisis by September. A missing contract is a minor headache one week, and a major price cut the next. One reason I wrote Sweat Equity Payday is that so much of your outcome as a seller is decided long before anyone signs on the dotted line.
At HartmannRhodes, I help owners of lower-middle-market companies across the country spot these issues while they’re still easy and inexpensive to fix—and manage them when the deal is underway. That means doing a readiness review that covers consents, paperwork, and financials, qualifying buyers before you give up your leverage, and running a process that keeps the timeline working in your favor.
You’ve spent decades building your business. The last three months shouldn’t be what determines whether you get paid what you’re worth.
You only sell your business once. Make it count.
If you’re thinking about a sale in the next few years and want to know where your closing risks actually sit, schedule a confidential discovery conversation.
Common Questions About Closing Risk in a Business Sale1) What is closing risk in a business sale? Closing risk is the chance that a signed deal doesn’t result in a wire transfer or results in one on materially worse terms. In lower-middle-market transactions, it falls into six categories: buyer financing, diligence findings, documentation gaps, third-party approvals, buyer behavior after exclusivity, and business performance during the process. Most of them are identifiable before a business goes to market. 2) Why do business sales fall apart after the LOI is signed? Because the LOI moves the deal from negotiation into verification. The buyer starts spending real money on accountants and attorneys, lenders begin their own approval process, and everything you represented gets tested. Deals come apart in that stretch when something surfaces that the seller hadn’t prepared for, when an outside approval takes longer than the timeline allows, or when the business slips while the owner is distracted. 3) What happens if the buyer’s financing falls through? Usually the deal doesn’t end cleanly. More often, the buyer returns with a restructured offer: a lower price, a larger seller note, an earnout, or a longer timeline while they find replacement capital. Your options depend on how much time you’ve lost, whether other buyers are still reachable, and what your exclusivity terms allow. Qualifying financing before granting exclusivity is far cheaper than negotiating this after. 4) Do I need my landlord’s approval to sell my business? Frequently, yes. Most commercial leases require landlord consent to assign the lease or to a change of control of the tenant. Landlords understand that timing gives them leverage, and consent requests made late in a deal can result in rent increases, extended terms, or a demand for a guarantee from the buyer. Review your lease before you go to market so you know what the consent process requires. 5) Can a customer contract block the sale of my business? A customer generally can’t stop the sale of your company, but assignment and change-of-control provisions can require their consent to keep the contract in place after closing. If that customer represents a meaningful share of revenue, a buyer will treat the consent as a closing condition. Read your largest agreements early, because contracts that need to be re-won after closing are worth less to a buyer than contracts that transfer. 6) How long do licensing and regulatory approvals take when selling a business It depends entirely on the state and the industry, and the range is wide. Some transfers are administrative and take days. Environmental transfer statutes, professional licensing where the license attaches to an individual, healthcare payer credentialing, and surety requalification for bonded contractors can add weeks or months. These timelines should be included in the deal schedule from the start rather than being discovered midway through diligence. 7) What can a seller do to reduce closing risk before going to market? Consider a sell-side QoE where the transaction's size or complexity warrants it. At minimum, prepare a documented earnings bridge, add-back file, and support for the financial claims presented to buyers. Organize corporate records, the cap table, and signed contracts. Inventory every consent your transaction will require and how long each takes. Qualify buyer financing before granting exclusivity. Assign diligence response to someone other than the person responsible for revenue. Then keep the business performing, because that’s the risk you control outright. |
Mark Hartmann is a former business owner turned M&A advisor—and the author of Sweat Equity Payday—who knows firsthand what it takes to build, grow, and sell a successful company. A three-time Inc. 5000 CEO honoree, he led his own eight-figure sale and now helps business owners sell companies worth $1M to $25M. Mark understands that selling a business is personal, not just financial. That’s why he works closely with owners to maximize value, protect their legacy, and transition on their terms.
He holds an MBA from Eastern University and a master's degree in organizational change management from St. Elizabeth University, as well as Certified M&A Professional (CM&AP), Certified Business Intermediary (CBI), Certified Exit Planning Advisor (CEPA), and Certified Value Builder (CVB) credentials.
44 Washington Street, Unit #1080
Morristown, NJ 07960
(855) 652-7577
HartmannRhodes advises owners of companies typically valued between $1–$25 million. If you’d like a structured pre-sale valuation review and a readiness roadmap, we can walk you through the process and tailor it to your timeline and goals. Contact us today!
Blog: Why Business Sales Fall Apart Before Closing: 6 Common Risks