Rollover Equity in a Business Sale: What It Is, How It Works, and Why It Matters

When you think about selling your business, you probably picture a clean break: a handshake, a wire transfer, and a sunset.

But what if you could sell most of your business, pocket the lion’s share of the value, and still retain a stake in its future growth?

That’s the power of rollover equity.

In today’s M&A landscape, especially in deals involving private equity or strategic buyers, rollover equity has become a common and strategic deal structure. It can be a win-win for sellers and buyers, but it’s not right for everyone.

So, whether you’re a business owner exploring your exit options or a buyer examining ways to align incentives, this post will clarify everything you need to know about rollover equity—what it is, how it works, and the benefits and drawbacks for both sides of the table.

---

What Is Rollover Equity?

Rollover equity (also called equity roll, retained equity, or a minority roll) refers to the portion of a seller’s ownership that is not sold but “rolled over” into the new ownership structure after the sale.

In plain English, the seller retains a stake in the business after the transaction, typically by converting part of their proceeds into equity in the new company.

This structure is common when:

• A private equity firm or strategic buyer acquires the business

• The seller is staying involved in a transitional or leadership role

• The buyer wants to align incentives and ensure continuity

It’s a way for sellers to cash out now but also benefit later, typically during a future sale (aka a “second bite at the apple”).

---

Cash now, upside later. Rollover equity lets you take most of your payout today while keeping a stake in future growth.

A Quick Example

Let’s say you sell your business for $10 million.

Instead of taking the full amount in cash at closing, the buyer offers:

• $8 million in cash upfront

• $2 million retained as equity (you now own 20% of the new entity)

That $2 million becomes rollover equity—your “skin in the game” for the next chapter.

If the buyer grows the business and sells it in five years for, say, $40 million, your 20% stake could be worth $8 million, netting you a second exit bigger than the first.

Sound intriguing? It is—but there are tradeoffs to consider.

---

Why Do Buyers Like Rollover Equity?

Buyers—mainly private equity firms—love rollover equity. Here’s why:

✅ 1. Alignment of Interests

Keeping the seller invested creates a powerful incentive. If the seller believes in the business and has a stake in its upside, they’re more likely to:

• Help with a smooth transition

• Stay engaged and motivated

• Provide valuable insight and leadership

✅ 2. Risk Reduction

Rollover equity helps ensure the seller doesn’t just take the money and run. It lowers perceived risk by maintaining operational continuity and institutional knowledge.

✅ 3. Less Cash Required at Closing

If the seller rolls over 20% of the deal value, the buyer only needs to fund 80% of the purchase price upfront—improving capital efficiency and returns.

✅ 4. Partnership Potential

Many buyers, especially financial sponsors, view the seller as a key partner. Rollover equity helps solidify that partnership.

---

Why Sellers Might Consider Rollover Equity

From a seller’s perspective, rollover equity can be a smart financial move—under the right conditions.

✅ 1. Second Bite at the Apple

This is the big one. If the buyer grows the business and exits in 3–7 years, your minority stake could be worth much more than what you rolled over.

Sometimes, sellers make more from their rollover equity than their initial sale proceeds.

✅ 2. Tax Efficiency

Rollover equity may offer deferred tax benefits under specific structures. Depending on how the deal is set up (stock sale vs. asset sale, C-corp vs. LLC), you may defer capital gains taxes on the rolled amount.

✅ 3. Stay Involved—But Less So

For owners who still want to participate—but at a reduced capacity—this structure offers a way to shift out of the driver’s seat while maintaining influence and upside.

✅ 4. Validation

If a sophisticated buyer wants you to stay on and share in the growth, that’s a vote of confidence in what you’ve built—and what they believe it can become.

---

There’s a right way through. Rollover equity can be risky—but with the right structure, it works.

But It’s Not All Upside: Rollover Risks and Drawbacks

Like anything in M&A, rollover equity isn’t all champagne and confetti. Sellers should understand the tradeoffs.

❌ 1. Your Liquidity Is Reduced

You’re taking less cash at closing. If your goal is a complete exit for retirement, that might not align with your personal financial plan.

❌ 2. You’re No Longer in Control

Once the deal closes, you’re a minority owner. The buyer controls the board, the budget, and the direction. Even if you disagree with the strategy, you may not have a say.

❌ 3. Future Exit Is Uncertain

That second bite at the apple? It’s speculative. If the new owner struggles, your rollover equity could be worth less—or nothing.

❌ 4. Tax Complexity

While rollover equity can be tax-efficient, it’s also more complex. Improperly structured deals can trigger immediate tax liabilities, especially if the rollover is treated as a taxable exchange.

❌ 5. Illiquidity

Your rolled equity is not publicly traded. You can’t cash it out whenever you want. You’re at the mercy of the buyer’s exit timeline.

---

Typical Rollover Equity Percentages

Rollover equity varies from deal to deal, but here’s what’s typical:

• Minority Rolls: 10% to 30% of deal value

• Larger Retentions: Up to 40% in PE platform deals

• Strategic Sales: Often 10–20% if the seller stays involved

In lower middle market deals ($5M–$25M), we commonly see 10% to 25% as a sweet spot—enough to keep sellers engaged but not overexposed.

---

Deal Structure Matters

Rollover equity can take a few forms, depending on the transaction structure and entities involved. The most common include:

🔹 Equity-for-Equity Swap

Seller contributes part of their business equity in exchange for shares in the new entity. This may qualify as a tax-deferred transaction under IRC Section 351 or 721.

🔹 Partial Cash-Out with Reinvestment

The seller receives all of the cash proceeds and reinvests a portion into the new entity. This is generally a taxable event on the whole amount.

🔹 Holdco Structure

The buyer sets up a new holding company to acquire the business. As part of the rollover, the seller receives a pro rata stake in Holdco.

Each structure has different legal, tax, and governance implications, so it’s essential to work with advisors who know how to structure it correctly.

---

What Sellers Should Ask Before Agreeing to a Rollover

If rollover equity is on the table, here are key questions sellers should ask:

1. How much control will I retain?

2. What kind of equity am I receiving? (common vs. preferred, voting vs. non-voting)

3. What rights do I have as a minority owner?

4. What’s the buyer’s exit plan? Timeline?

5. How will my equity be valued if the buyer brings in new investors?

6. What happens if the business underperforms or fails?

7. Will I be required to guarantee debt or reinvest future earnings?

8. Is this tax-deferred or taxable now?

Don’t go into a rollover deal without legal and tax counsel. The details make all the difference.

---

For Buyers: Making Rollover Equity Work

If you’re a buyer (especially a financial buyer), rollover equity is a tool—but it only works if the seller trusts you and your vision.

Here’s how to make it appealing:

• Be transparent about your growth strategy and exit plans

• Offer fair terms—not all rollover equity is created equal

• Provide clarity on governance, distributions, and exit mechanics

• Respect the seller’s post-sale role (and limits)

Rollover equity is ultimately about partnership—so structure it like one.

---

First bite in hand. The second could be your biggest reward.

Real-World Example: A Rollover Success Story

Let’s say a business owner sells 80% of their HVAC company to a private equity firm for $10 million and rolls over 20% ($2 million) into the new entity.

The firm brings in professional management, adds new locations, and grows EBITDA from $2M to $5M. They sell to a larger PE group for a 12x multiple five years later.

That original 20% stake? Now worth $12 million.

That’s the second bite of the apple—sweet, isn’t it?

Of course, not every story ends that way. However, when deals are structured well, and partners are aligned, rollover equity can be a powerful wealth-building tool for sellers who believe in the next chapter.

---

Final Thoughts

Rollover equity isn’t just a financial lever—it’s a strategic decision.

For buyers, it’s a way to de-risk the deal, retain talent, and align incentives.

For sellers, it’s a chance to benefit from future growth while stepping back from day-to-day operations. But it comes with tradeoffs: less cash upfront, less control, and more complexity.

At HartmannRhodes, we guide sellers through these choices every day. From deal structure and negotiation to tax strategy and post-sale planning, we help you weigh your options—so you can transition on your terms.

Because you spent decades building your business, it’s time to make the exit count—and maybe, just maybe, take that second bite of the apple.

---

Thinking About Selling?

We’d love to talk. Let’s explore what rollover equity might look like in your deal—and how to maximize your outcome.

📅 Schedule a confidential consultation today.

Blog: Rollover Equity in a Business Sale: What It Is, How It Works, and Why It Matters

Mark Hartmann is a former business owner turned M&A advisor who knows firsthand what it takes to build, grow, and sell a successful company. A three-time Inc. 5000 CEO, Mark did just that before navigating its eight-figure sale—giving him a rare perspective that sets him apart from most brokers. Today, he helps owners of companies valued between $1M and $25M plan and execute smooth, profitable exits.

Mark understands that selling a business isn’t just a financial decision—it’s personal. That’s why he works closely with owners to protect their legacy, maximize value, and make the transition on their terms. He holds an MBA from Eastern University, a Master’s Degree in Organizational Change Management from St. Elizabeth University, and a Graduate Certificate in Executive Coaching from Columbia University. Some of his professional credentials include Certified Mergers & Acquisitions Professional (CM&AP), Certified Business Intermediary (CBI), Certified Exit Planning Advisor (CEPA), and Certified Value Builder (CVB).

Serving NJ, NY, CT, PA, & DE

44 Washington Street, Unit #1080

Morristown, NJ 07960

(973) 296-9507

Schedule a Call or Zoom

Partner with HartmannRhodes, expert business brokers and M&A advisors, to navigate your business sale with precision—maximizing value and ensuring a smooth transition. Reach out for tailored business sale strategies. Contact us today!